In defense of #notallmen.
I have been
reading the commentary on social media attached to the #yesallwomen and
#notallmen hashtags with some interest over the past week or so.
It has been said that responding to women’s wariness of men by pointing out that #notallmen are disrespectors of women is unhelpful because it derails the discussion and disregards the experience that women are trying to convey, effectively undermining the voices of those women and continuing the cycle of oppression.
In the wake of
the Eliot Rodger shooting, women have given
voice to
the
sometimes-frightening day-to-day reality of being a woman in a world of male
entitlement and the default mistrust of men that many women have come to feel. In response, a defensive cohort of men have entered the discussion to
remind women that #notallmen are like that.
It has been said that responding to women’s wariness of men by pointing out that #notallmen are disrespectors of women is unhelpful because it derails the discussion and disregards the experience that women are trying to convey, effectively undermining the voices of those women and continuing the cycle of oppression.
In addition, it has been commented that women already know that
#notallmen are a threat; that reminding them of this is not only redundant, but
a misunderstanding of the point that women must unfortunately treat all men
with suspicion because they can’t know in advance which men are safe and which
are not.
So the #yesallwomen hashtag has emerged to neutralise the distraction of #notallmen and refocus the discussion on women’s perspectives.
So the #yesallwomen hashtag has emerged to neutralise the distraction of #notallmen and refocus the discussion on women’s perspectives.
To be absolutely clear, I want to acknowledge the importance and
legitimacy of the concerns that women are raising in this discussion. But let’s
not be quite so hasty to dismiss #notallmen as an irrelevant distraction from
the main issue. You see, the reason this tagline has struck such a chord with
men is that it
represents a genuinely hurtful and damaging common male experience; and one that
is inextricably linked to the issues that women are trying to communicate.
This is the experience of having someone react with suspicion/negativity
towards you simply because you are a man.
Does this seem
petty? It's not! Believe it or not, it matters to most men what women think of
them. As anyone who has ever been subjected to prejudice knows, systematic
vilification or condescension by members of a group who see you as an outsider
can be extremely damaging to a person, with real mental health outcomes
associated.
If this sounds
familiar to women, well that's exactly my point. The #yesallwomen vs #notallmen
discussion seems to have descended into a ridiculous posturing for the moral
high ground regarding whose perspective is more valid. Let me give you some
examples:
1) This quote,
attributed to Margret Atwood, has been cited continuously:
Men are afraid that women will laugh at them. Women are afraid that
men will kill them.
By implication,
women's fears trump men's fears, therefore we can dismiss men's fears as
irrelevant.
2) This tweet
from Martin Wagner @wagnerfilm:
"UNFAIR! NOT ALL MEN!" Imagine a bowl of
M&Ms. 10% of them are poisoned. Go ahead. Eat a handful. Not all M&Ms
are poison.
The message here
is clear: women’s fear of men is reasonable and rational, therefore men have no
right to be upset about it.
3) This article
by Clementine Ford:
Clementine Ford
suggests that any man who rejects the notion that they are someone of whose
potential for violence, disrespect or objectification women are
reasonably afraid, is precisely that person.
Ironically, by illegitimising men’s attempts to express their frustration with women’s
attitudes towards them, Clementine Ford has committed the same crime against
men that she is accusing men of committing against women.
Why must we
dismiss one person’s perspective in order to hear another’s? I think that if we
actually want to promote an understanding (as opposed to a cathartic airing of
grievances) we can't afford to dismiss anyone's experience as irrelevant.
It's not ok
that women are made to feel fear, simply as a function of their being female.
And it's not ok that men are made to feel shame, simply as a function of their
being male. There is no either/or. It is both and they are intertwined.
There is a final
point worth making. This article is a revision of a rambling comment I made on
Facebook several days ago. Through the constructive discussion generated I have
been drawn deeper into this debate and considered the issues in more detail
than I ever have before. Had my offerings been derided as just another example
of privileged male ignorance, I might have bowed out and missed the opportunity
to increase my awareness of and appreciation for the difficulties that women
experience. If we dismiss the contributions of those we consider misinformed,
we are just venting to those who already relate to and understand our
experience.
So once again, let’s not be so hasty to label
#notallmen an irrelevant distraction. It might be just the hook by which to
draw men into the discussion.